M1028: The Sweet Food Consensus - Game Thread

[brainbomb]

Aren't you normally much more wary, and cognizant of Jamie's slips, gaffes and failures to be consistent?

Why are you giving a free pass to that here?

this post is @ ghug

[Kakarroto]

It's probably just worcej/Kak.

ok, a bit confused here, do you mean Will + one of worcej/me or that the team is 'only' wor and me? Because I can guarantee you that the latter would be wrong

ah well, I guess you can't make a cake without breaking some eggs and stuff anyway

Sad I caught you?

sorry to disappoint you, I'll listen to your apology in the god thread later

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

##VOTE JAMIE

[Kakarroto]

@RD when you come around to reading the thread, I'd like your input about the jamie situation, and who do you currently think is the most likely mafia, please.

[sweetandcool]

Official Vote Count 1.1

Jamiet99uk (3) brainbomb, Kakarroto, JustAGuyNamedWill
worcej (1) damo666
Diplomacy&Warfare (1) Jamiet99uk

Currently, Jamiet99uk is slated to be baked a cake decorated with UwU faces.

End of day is in 28.5 hours.

[damo666]

I figure damo is town as well because he is already annoying me

[damo666]

@Kak games usually start on a Monday evening and I tend to be unavailable.

alright, fair, I think I remember you have some things monday going, though what was it again? pub quiz night?

still, you didn't think that pressuring worcej might cause him to claim if he is PR? That is just atypical of the damo that openly is against any slightest comments that might give mafia the edge in PR hunting. This feels more like mafia damo trying to use a joke to get info so to out a PR or make the pool for it smaller.

poker

I don't think one joke vote is gonna force worcej to claim PR (should he be one).

[damo666]

if damo is town the best thing I can do for myself, is to speak coherently, and loud enough to make other players actually listen. I know from experience that no matter how artful, accurate or factual my scum pushes are, he simply will go his own way and disregard it all as brainbombisms.

I'll try not be dismissive.

[ghug]

Aren't you normally much more wary, and cognizant of Jamie's slips, gaffes and failures to be consistent?

Why are you giving a free pass to that here?

this post is @ ghug

I don't think that's an accurate assessment of how I read Jamie. I think he's a good scum player who isn't especially prone to those sorts of mistakes. It's more tone, motive, and emotion that I look for to read Jamie.

I think he's more likely to be scum here than you or Will, but more because he provoked y'all with the seven thing and then was very level-headed in responding. My mind immediately jumped to the conclusion that he was being silly when he made the seven comment. I think y'all are making a mountain out of a molehill.

[ghug]

##VOTE JAMIE

WHY ARE WE YELLING??

[ghug]

@Kak games usually start on a Monday evening and I tend to be unavailable.

alright, fair, I think I remember you have some things monday going, though what was it again? pub quiz night?

still, you didn't think that pressuring worcej might cause him to claim if he is PR? That is just atypical of the damo that openly is against any slightest comments that might give mafia the edge in PR hunting. This feels more like mafia damo trying to use a joke to get info so to out a PR or make the pool for it smaller.

poker

I don't think one joke vote is gonna force worcej to claim PR (should he be one).

He's done it before.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

##VOTE JAMIE

WHY ARE WE YELLING??

Habit

[damo666]

I think Jamie is town here. I see nothing scummy.

I reckon there's at least one in D&W worcej and rdr.

Everyone else seems too towny. I can't have two misreads.

But I can have one so maybe Jamie is scum. Or ghug. Or Kak. Or Will. Or brain.

[brainbomb]

How would D&W being town change your opinion on Jamie.

As far as I can tell the biggest incident of the game so far was D&W asking PRs to mass claim, and then also voting no kill.

With that move he drew considerable attention onto himself and Jamie voted him.

If D&W is scum, then Jamie is just doing great town work and Jamie is probably not bussing.

If D&W is town, Jamie is almost certainly scum who found the absolute perfect target to tunnel day 1, because D&W is either a PR or an easy miskill.

[brainbomb]

I think Jamie is scum here and D&W is probably town

they are not on a scumteam together, and very unlikely to both be town in my humble opine

[damo666]

I think Jamie is scum here and D&W is probably town

they are not on a scumteam together, and very unlikely to both be town in my humble opine

Scan one, kill one?

[brainbomb]

Aren't you normally much more wary, and cognizant of Jamie's slips, gaffes and failures to be consistent?

Why are you giving a free pass to that here?

this post is @ ghug

I don't think that's an accurate assessment of how I read Jamie. I think he's a good scum player who isn't especially prone to those sorts of mistakes. It's more tone, motive, and emotion that I look for to read Jamie.

I think he's more likely to be scum here than you or Will, but more because he provoked y'all with the seven thing and then was very level-headed in responding. My mind immediately jumped to the conclusion that he was being silly when he made the seven comment. I think y'all are making a mountain out of a molehill.

This is fine. Decent reply.
If not Jamie I would vote kak here, and maybe will to a lesser extent.

would have to think about if scum will would really try to push a PR massclaim and play as brazen scum two games in a row

[brainbomb]

Official Vote Count 1.0

worcej (1) damo666
ghug (1) JustAGuyNamedWill
No Kill (1) Diplomacy&Warfare*

Currently, nobody is slated to be force fed sweet pastries.
45 hours left to vote.

This count account was wrong by the way.
Ghug had voted for Will, and the bot didnt pick this up.

also ghug vote is still not in the bot and unless the GM rules it is a valid vote ghugs vote was invalid.

@ghug are you going to correct this yourself or wait for a GM ruling.

##Call GM will you be using the bot for official votes or will votes for %%Vote Will) be counted also?

[brainbomb]

##VOTE Will

Ghug, you silly old space cube.

Did you deliberately post this vote in an invalid format, or did you not realise?

I agree with Ghug that mech talk today is a suboptimal topic of conversation.

Who is giving good vibes? Who is giving bad vibes? Who is trying to fly under the radar? These sorts of things should be in our minds.

@Jamie, your first post above, asks ghug if he deliberately voted in an invalid format

one post later you ask about who is giving bad vibes, and trying to fly under the radar.

If you were sincerely curious about if ghug was using a invalid vote on will, would that fit the criteria of trying to fly under the radar? and would that also fulfil the bad vibes?

It seems like you gave this a pass without ghug even answering you

[foodcoats]

Official Vote Count 1.0

worcej (1) damo666
ghug (1) JustAGuyNamedWill
No Kill (1) Diplomacy&Warfare*

Currently, nobody is slated to be force fed sweet pastries.
45 hours left to vote.

This count account was wrong by the way.
Ghug had voted for Will, and the bot didnt pick this up.

also ghug vote is still not in the bot and unless the GM rules it is a valid vote ghugs vote was invalid.

@ghug are you going to correct this yourself or wait for a GM ruling.

##Call GM will you be using the bot for official votes or will votes for %%Vote Will) be counted also?

The bot is the arbiter of the vote count except at EOD. I would count ##VOTE Will as a vote for JustAGuyNamedWill if that was someone’s final vote of the day.