M1027: Community - Game Thread

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Heart first posted about the 3 person scan at 3:58pm PST (so 4:00pm). The argument was then resolved around page 93 at 6:42pm PST (so 6:45pm)

That took us approx. 2:45 to propose, argue about, and resolve the plan.

It was not resolved at all.

Everyone except you (although I assume you will do it anyway) agrees and has stated that the Investigate 3 plan is the best we have come up with. Even BK agrees, and his life is on the line!

[Jamiet99uk]

Heart first posted about the 3 person scan at 3:58pm PST (so 4:00pm). The argument was then resolved around page 93 at 6:42pm PST (so 6:45pm)

That took us approx. 2:45 to propose, argue about, and resolve the plan.

It was not resolved at all.

Everyone except you (although I assume you will do it anyway) agrees and has stated that the Investigate 3 plan is the best we have come up with. Even BK agrees, and his life is on the line!

If B3K3Y2J and Sweet are both town, I expect Worcej and either Chaqa or Rdr are the final scumpair.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

If any of you have a better plan please bring it up. More than happy to contribute to a town win.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

It was not resolved at all.

Everyone except you (although I assume you will do it anyway) agrees and has stated that the Investigate 3 plan is the best we have come up with. Even BK agrees, and his life is on the line!

If B3K3Y2J and Sweet are both town, I expect Worcej and either Chaqa or Rdr are the final scumpair.

You are somehow simultaneously the most suspicious person still alive and the person I’m least likely to vote for.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Everyone except you (although I assume you will do it anyway) agrees and has stated that the Investigate 3 plan is the best we have come up with. Even BK agrees, and his life is on the line!

If B3K3Y2J and Sweet are both town, I expect Worcej and either Chaqa or Rdr are the final scumpair.

You are somehow simultaneously the most suspicious person still alive and the person I’m least likely to vote for.

But yes i agree. But I think rdr is most likely to be scum of the 3. Just has not helped at ALL. At least worcej tried.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

If B3K3Y2J and Sweet are both town, I expect Worcej and either Chaqa or Rdr are the final scumpair.

You are somehow simultaneously the most suspicious person still alive and the person I’m least likely to vote for.

But yes i agree. But I think rdr is most likely to be scum of the 3. Just has not helped at ALL. At least worcej tried.

Not “Just!” Rdr! Wow words dont work today

[sweetandcool]

I'm pretty sure scumteam is Will and Heart.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I'm pretty sure scumteam is Will and Heart.

Guess we’ll see. I would be fine if the investigator picked me. Got nothing to hide

[Jamiet99uk]

Everyone except you (although I assume you will do it anyway) agrees and has stated that the Investigate 3 plan is the best we have come up with. Even BK agrees, and his life is on the line!

If B3K3Y2J and Sweet are both town, I expect Worcej and either Chaqa or Rdr are the final scumpair.

You are somehow simultaneously the most suspicious person still alive and the person I’m least likely to vote for.

I think we might be team-mates.

[BK3K]

It was not resolved at all.

Everyone except you (although I assume you will do it anyway) agrees and has stated that the Investigate 3 plan is the best we have come up with. Even BK agrees, and his life is on the line!

If B3K3Y2J and Sweet are both town, I expect Worcej and either Chaqa or Rdr are the final scumpair.

I boldly predict rdr is one of them

[Chaqa]

I plan to follow Just's Will

[BK3K]

I'm pretty sure scumteam is Will and Heart.

Except this plan is good. I wish he went, but I think Will is town. My biggest complaint is how confident he was and unwilling to discuss. He go really lucky that investigation is in our favor, otherwise he'd look way worse

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

If B3K3Y2J and Sweet are both town, I expect Worcej and either Chaqa or Rdr are the final scumpair.

You are somehow simultaneously the most suspicious person still alive and the person I’m least likely to vote for.

I think we might be team-mates.

Hope so

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I'm pretty sure scumteam is Will and Heart.

Except this plan is good. I wish he went, but I think Will is town. My biggest complaint is how confident he was and unwilling to discuss. He go really lucky that investigation is in our favor, otherwise he'd look way worse

That was on me. It never really crossed my mind that the investigator didn’t get their scan if they died.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I'm pretty sure scumteam is Will and Heart.

Except this plan is good. I wish he went, but I think Will is town. My biggest complaint is how confident he was and unwilling to discuss. He go really lucky that investigation is in our favor, otherwise he'd look way worse

That was on me. It never really crossed my mind that the investigator didn’t get their scan if they died.

I really thought I had something, and when sweet immediately pushed back I assume it was because, as scum, he didn’t want to get caught with my plan.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Right but how do you find out whether B3K is aligned with Sweet, by not investigating B3K?

Sweet and I are already mechanically guaranteed to be aligned from last night's investigation. I made a chart that I think shows Just's plan to be pretty tight. I don't want to do all the analysis on Sweets plan.



VT Vote BK3K

In the above, you can ignore the two scenarios where X is night killed and the cop. Co-op can't investigate self

One question:
Does this mean that the investigator mechanically cannot investigate themselves?

Or does this mean that the investigator reasonably should not investigate themself, thus rendering those possibilities obsolete?

[BK3K]

Sweet and I are already mechanically guaranteed to be aligned from last night's investigation. I made a chart that I think shows Just's plan to be pretty tight. I don't want to do all the analysis on Sweets plan.



VT Vote BK3K

In the above, you can ignore the two scenarios where X is night killed and the cop. Co-op can't investigate self

One question:
Does this mean that the investigator mechanically cannot investigate themselves?

Or does this mean that the investigator reasonably should not investigate themself, thus rendering those possibilities obsolete?

Mechanically cannot

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Been 2 hours without discussion. I don’t want the last few days to be a snoozefest.

[sweetandcool]

@Chaqa,

Is this going to be your first kid?

[heartthrob24909]

6 hours is not enough time to form a plan. An extra 24 hours would have been nice.

Okay, we may as well vote BK3K and get an actual result.

Just send in BK3K folks, and hope this doesn't completely blow up.

Why is this not enough time? I did the math for heart’s plan (because he was the first to put out the idea of a 3 person scan, sorry heart) in about 20 minutes and our full discussion ended within four or less hours.

I am happy to share the plan creds with you lol... you did a great job fleshing out the different scenarios, I dont think I have any more ownership over the idea than you do