M72 - “Echoes of Evelyn” - Game Thread [HIDDEN]

[Jamiet99uk]

I assume I am wrong.

Personally my strategy is usually to Roleblock someone like Brainbomb or Ghug so that when they claim the Roleblock everyone thinks "hmmm, that's fishy, who would want to roleblock that guy?"

I'm pretty sure my disdain for roleblocking the kill target when there are multiple PRs alive is almost a meme by now, and it definitely came up earlier in the game.

Yes but the problem with you yourself using this as a point in your defence is that it is very wifom-y.

[Chaqa]

I assume I am wrong.

Personally my strategy is usually to Roleblock someone like Brainbomb or Ghug so that when they claim the Roleblock everyone thinks "hmmm, that's fishy, who would want to roleblock that guy?"

I'm pretty sure my disdain for roleblocking the kill target when there are multiple PRs alive is almost a meme by now, and it definitely came up earlier in the game.

Yes but the problem with you yourself using this as a point in your defence is that it is very wifom-y.

I wasn't the first one to use it, I don't think. This debate happened on Day 2 and Night 2, or somewhere thereabouts.

Why aren't you reading the thread?

[ghug]

If ghug is mafia I will literally stop playing for six months.

I'm being buddied and it feels so good.

[Chaqa]

If ghug is mafia I will literally stop playing for six months.

I'm being buddied and it feels so good.

It's a win win

Either I'm right or I can take a break from playing mafia lol

[Maniac]

RIP Kgray

##vote Ghug, because I love a good meme

Scum not killing goldfinger or me is a bit of a head scratcher. If we’re both town then leaving us alive could be fatal to them as soon as the godfather is discovered. Does this mean they are confident that godfather is well hidden?

[rdrivera2005]

RIP Kgray

##vote Ghug, because I love a good meme

Scum not killing goldfinger or me is a bit of a head scratcher. If we’re both town then leaving us alive could be fatal to them as soon as the godfather is discovered. Does this mean they are confident that godfather is well hidden?

Or that one of you is GF....

[Chaqa]

I’m back and forth on Maniac.

Given the game state when he claimed, I’m not sure scum would want to go 1:1 with the Cop there, but also it would depend on if he thought the cop would even CC. Maybe he was hoping the cop would scan him that night?

I kinda think he could be town. I also think gold is probably town, but one of them could obviously be GF.

We can start thinking about it later

[BobMcBob]

I don't know. The interactions I had with HR made me think he was town. Voting him would more due to PoE than a pure scumread - that's how most of this goes for me.

If not Donny today, I would rather vote out Damo or Rivera than HR.

Bob is also an option, but he falls more into the "probably shouldn't let him get to the endgame" camp than the "this player oozes scum" camp.

What exactly would be the problem with me in the endgame?

[Donny Dude]

I dont get chaqa point on endgame
If eliminating me would me not having to deal with me in the endgame ,then that would leave more of a better scum anyways
I have been dealing with school and such, but so.
Why would maniac and bob not be in the same boat then?

[Chaqa]

I don't know. The interactions I had with HR made me think he was town. Voting him would more due to PoE than a pure scumread - that's how most of this goes for me.

If not Donny today, I would rather vote out Damo or Rivera than HR.

Bob is also an option, but he falls more into the "probably shouldn't let him get to the endgame" camp than the "this player oozes scum" camp.

What exactly would be the problem with me in the endgame?

If you’re town, you’ll probably get miskiled if you’re around at LYLO

[BobMcBob]

I don't know. The interactions I had with HR made me think he was town. Voting him would more due to PoE than a pure scumread - that's how most of this goes for me.

If not Donny today, I would rather vote out Damo or Rivera than HR.

Bob is also an option, but he falls more into the "probably shouldn't let him get to the endgame" camp than the "this player oozes scum" camp.

What exactly would be the problem with me in the endgame?

If you’re town, you’ll probably get miskiled if you’re around at LYLO

So instead we miskill me now and call it a win?

[Donny Dude]

Not a fan of goldy post today about blank person not dying.

[Chaqa]

I dont get chaqa point on endgame
If eliminating me would me not having to deal with me in the endgame ,then that would leave more of a better scum anyways
I have been dealing with school and such, but so.
Why would maniac and bob not be in the same boat then?

Basically, if you’re town, you’ve been very low activity on the game lately, and I’m concerned you wouldn’t have as much perspective on how things have developed to make a decision later

[Chaqa]

What exactly would be the problem with me in the endgame?

If you’re town, you’ll probably get miskiled if you’re around at LYLO

So instead we miskill me now and call it a win?

Basically. If we do it now, the mafia have much harder nightkill choices to make as well.

Im not 100% in on it, much like the TFB situation was, but it’s something I’m considering because we’re kinda in a weird spot here

We’re very ahead but also have little info to work with

[Donny Dude]

I dont get chaqa point on endgame
If eliminating me would me not having to deal with me in the endgame ,then that would leave more of a better scum anyways
I have been dealing with school and such, but so.
Why would maniac and bob not be in the same boat then?

Basically, if you’re town, you’ve been very low activity on the game lately, and I’m concerned you wouldn’t have as much perspective on how things have developed to make a decision later

K, thats fair,
but I feel like you are substituting it for looking for scum a bit.
I will try and be more active from now on since
I have a better handle on school hopefully.

[Chaqa]

I dont get chaqa point on endgame
If eliminating me would me not having to deal with me in the endgame ,then that would leave more of a better scum anyways
I have been dealing with school and such, but so.
Why would maniac and bob not be in the same boat then?

Basically, if you’re town, you’ve been very low activity on the game lately, and I’m concerned you wouldn’t have as much perspective on how things have developed to make a decision later

K, thats fair,
but I feel like you are substituting it for looking for scum a bit.
I will try and be more active from now on since
I have a better handle on school hopefully.

Well, partiality I was hoping to bring you out of your hidey hole.

I don’t really think we should be putting anyone out of the PoE. Except ghug.

And probably TFB

[Maniac]

There is a very good chance goldfinger is G/F and I’m fully aware that if I’m right I have to die tonight, but that’s fine.

I can’t see scum opting to kill Kgray unless they are confident that GF isn’t going to get killed. I was an advocate of taking myself and goldie off the chopping block yesterday believing that we had better chance of hitting scum from the remaining players. But the G/F is so key to scum that they are willing to reduce the non scanned pool in favour of reducing the scanned pool and maybe increase risk of us hitting the remaining goon, just to protect the G/F.

Also goldie said yesterday he’d have more time to scum hunting today! I fully expected one of us to die last night, but goldie seemed confident he’d survive.

##vote goldie

[Chaqa]

There is a very good chance goldfinger is G/F and I’m fully aware that if I’m right I have to die tonight, but that’s fine.

I can’t see scum opting to kill Kgray unless they are confident that GF isn’t going to get killed. I was an advocate of taking myself and goldie off the chopping block yesterday believing that we had better chance of hitting scum from the remaining players. But the G/F is so key to scum that they are willing to reduce the non scanned pool in favour of reducing the scanned pool and maybe increase risk of us hitting the remaining goon, just to protect the G/F.

Also goldie said yesterday he’d have more time to scum hunting today! I fully expected one of us to die last night, but goldie seemed confident he’d survive.

##vote goldie

And if we kill Goldie and he's a VT, we've lost both of our clears come tomorrow. I don't think that vote is a good idea.

[BesharamSabi]

VOTE COUNT VERSION 6.02

ghug (2) goldfinger0303 rdrivera2005
Hellenic Riot (2) damo666 Jamiet99uk
Jamiet99uk (1) ghug
BobMcBob (1) TheFlyingBoat
Donny Dude (1) Chaqa
goldfinger0303 (1) Maniac

Non-votes: BobMcBob,, Donny Dude, Hellenic Riot

NO ONE IS SET TO WALK IN LEGOS FOR ALL OF ETERNITY

EOD is in 24 hours and 48 minutes


The most reproduced image in the world is Mickey Mouse, which can be found on over 7,500 different items

[TheFlyingBoat]

@ghug this is your requested reminder to read my post