You mean Utility based morality arguments.

Or a Doctor who will find the cure for all cancers , but also kills children. If you improson him he will refuse to find the cure . So do you ket him keep on killing for the rest of his life so on his deathbed he tells everyone the cure or do you stop him now ?? Morality is a POV not a fixed point.

What if science could prove there was an absolute certain moral pathway that was accepted by a deity

What if morality was just a general "Don't be an asshole"

who cares about moral decisions, just so long as you are making them with the best intent

You guys are all whack!

The sun shines whether it is day or night, or you can see it or not or if you believe it or don't. What is, is. Morality exists whether you particate or refrain. And the train and doctor anecdotes are straw men for people who would rather choose their way rather than the right way.

The "right way " , The " just dont be an asshole" are still subjective POV's. and not firm or fixed morality..

BB I dont want to debate morality..for this threads sake pick a diety and we can discuss the benifits of spaming indulenges on webdip for afterlife benifits.

I'm not sure what "an afterlife based on morality means". If you're referring to the system where God gives you credit for doing good shit and you lose credit with God for doing bad shit and your final score determines whether you go to heaven or hell, then the result of discovering this would obviously be that evil long-term thinkers go to heaven because they really wanna grab that pussy but they already used up most of their God-credits so they gotta save some up first.

Coincidentally, this is why I would be immensely disappointed if there was a God according to traditional Christian (and other) belief(s). I want to live my life doing what I consider to be the right thing because I give my life meaning in this way. I would feel utterly disappointed if I found out that I've been scoring points.

INQUISITOR: You have been granted the greatest gift of all: the gift of
life. Tell me, what you have done to deserve this superlative good
fortune?
RIMMER: Well, I say this with the highest respect, but what gives you the
right to ask -- no, actually -- demand that answer of me, Your
Magnificence? (He curtsies and bows.)
INQUISITOR: All must answer to the Inquisitor!
RIMMER: But how do I know I'll get a fair hearing?
INQUISITOR: Because, like all who stand before the Inquisitor, your judge
shall be...

The INQUISITOR lifts his facemask to reveal... RIMMER's face.

INQUISITOR: ...yourself!
RIMMER: Oh smeg!
INQUISITOR: "Oh smeg," indeed, matey!
RIMMER: Everyone is judged by their own self?
INQUISITOR: It's a bit metaphysical, I know, but it's the only fair way.
Now then, justify yourself.
RIMMER: Well, first I--
INQUISITOR: (Interrupting) Liar!
RIMMER: I've done good things.
INQUISITOR: No, you haven't!
RIMMER: In my heart, I've always tried to do good things.
INQUISITOR: No, you didn't.
RIMMER: Look, in my way, I've tried to lead a good life.
INQUISITOR: When?
RIMMER: Ah! (Points off behind the throne) What's that in the corner?
It's the archangel Gabriel! Well, that's me converted, I'm a new man!
Hallelujah!
INQUISITOR: You are a slimy, despicable, rat-hearted, green-discharge of
a man, aren't you?
RIMMER: Well... sort of, yes.
INQUISITOR: So then, _justify_ yourself!
RIMMER: What else could I have been? My father was a half-crazed
military failure, my mother was a bitch-queen from hell. My brothers
had all the looks and talent. What did I have? Unmanageable hair and
ingrowing toenails. Yes, I admit I'm nothing. But from what I started
with, nothing is up.