webdiplomacy.net

Foxcastle wrote: ↑

Sat Aug 22, 2020 9:00 pm

Here's my VCA. I've left myself out, because someone else should do that for me.

EMC. EMC's Day 2 and 4 look townie. He went to Chaqa freely with four minutes to go (this was after Flash softed, but before he claimed), and in doing so, dropped the Hamilton wagon out of a 2-vote lead. On D4, he pushed Bo at a critical time, tying him for the lead wagon.

Bozo. Bozo could have been scum D1 watching town hang itself. On D2, he was on Flash, and then shifted to Chaqa just before Flash claimed—although Flash had softed a few couple minutes before, so maybe he saw the writing on the wall? He was voting for one of the contending wagons (Flash) and then said "I'm OK with any of the three" as he voted Chaqa. If he was okay with any of the three, why make put Chaqa in the lead? Maybe he saw Flash softing, wanted credit for bussing, but didn't want to create a rush off flash?

Durga. I think Durga is town, so someone else can go dig into her VCA, but she does push Chaqa at a critical time on D2.

Hamilton. D2, he was getting voted by both Chaqa and Ghug pretty much the whole last two hours before EOD. That makes me think it's pretty unlikely that Hamilton is scum.

Rdrivera. I don't think Rdr is scum, but his VCA isn't helping him. There's not much to read, but on D2, he sat on Yoyo and pushed Flash over Hamilton and Chaqa when they had all been tied.

Summit. If summit is scum, D1 was TvT, and he made several moves late in the day. I think scum-Summit would have been content to sit and watch. He also pushed Chaqa at a critical time on D2 (the second vote on the wagon 30 minutes out), but then didn't move off when Durga and TrP piled on, even though there was plenty of time to find somewhere else to land. He also pushed Bo at a critical time on D4.

TrPrado. D1 isn't much. D2 pushes Chaqa at an important time.

Worcej. Worcej's VCA isn't doing much for him. D1 and D4 don’t tell much. D2, he sat on Summit until 10 minutes out, then moved to Hamilton. It could be a move to protect Chaqa—if it is, it's Worcej being super clever, because the more obvious move to save Chaqa would have been to push Flash farther ahead.

Bob. Nothing worth noting. But Bo's D4 might be exculpatory for him. Bo voted for Bob immediately on D4 before disappearing for most of the day. That seems like iffy scum play if Bob is also scum, but I think it's within range of Bo's play.

So I think my preferred vote order is: Bozo > Worcej > TrPrado > Rdrivera > Summit > Bob > EMC > Durga > Hamilton

Hamilton Brian wrote: ↑

Sun Aug 23, 2020 3:52 am

Where have I seen this played out before? Durga,If Bob flips town, are you willing to get hung next?

Durga wrote: ↑

Sun Aug 23, 2020 4:02 am

I'm ending on bob because the day is dead and we have enough miskills that it doesn't actually matter.

Hamilton Brian wrote: ↑

Sun Aug 23, 2020 4:06 am

Durga wrote: ↑

Sun Aug 23, 2020 4:02 am

I'm ending on bob because the day is dead and we have enough miskills that it doesn't actually matter.

Just bitter recent memory.

summit_fever wrote: ↑

Sun Aug 23, 2020 4:12 am

I'll end if I can know the result now.

##CALL GM

You around?