https://www.webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3/
https://www.webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=1179
Has anyone posted a non-hedgy readlist?LordQuas wrote: ↑Sat Jan 12, 2019 6:12 pmthis read list is also very hedgyflash2015 wrote: ↑Sat Jan 12, 2019 4:56 pmFox is still top of my list. I agree with Bozo's analysis above. The way he did his Askia reveal is still sus. I don't really see what info we gained from Demon's choosing of Squiggs - whether Demon is scum OR town he had to target Squiggs. It is NAI. The only thing Demon perhaps could have done better here was wait a little longer.
Don't know what to think of darg but Worcej theory is as good as any. I won't be unhappy if he gets lynched.
LQ - You could be right. He could be SK, but probably town.
Nepthys - probably town? I am not sure about the two plans he proposed though.
Jamiet - probably town?
Too lazy to think about the rest. Fox and darg should be our wagons for today - since tomorrow there will be three less people, there will be less work for me to do. And I can start thinking PoE which I like better.
Actually you were the first to vote Bozo D3 so you put him in the lead! So what was your reason?Jamiet99uk wrote: ↑Sat Jan 12, 2019 7:10 pmI put my vote on Bozo when he was one of the lead wagons.
Latterly I re-entered that vote so it would show on the bot for anyone doing VCA.
I am now satisfied to ##VOTE FOXCASTLE
Because he's had consistently high engagement, and had numerous very towny looking arguments with many people. As I noted, it's for this phase and so I don't think that he is someone we would even debate lynching rn
The orchestrated fight with demon mostlyLordQuas wrote: ↑Sat Jan 12, 2019 6:14 pmdamo666 wrote: ↑Sat Jan 12, 2019 6:06 pmI'm not particularly SK and I don't understand how you say I am not scum hunting. There are 5 outstanding anti-town roles 4 scum and 1 SK. I am endeavouring to identify as many of the 5 as I can. I suspect a minimum of 2 from Fox/LordQ/demonRHK with the rest from worcej/darg/Durga/flash. Of course I could be misreading Bozo Jamie or Neph but I doubt it. I don't see that as 'hedgy'.LordQuas wrote: ↑Sat Jan 12, 2019 5:55 pmdamo's read list is pathetically weak and hedgy, he's also SK hunting instead of wolf hunting, which A) doesn't really work as SK's "tone" shouldn't really be any different then a town, that's why it's so hard to hunt one, B) the SK is prolly lurking as to not attract much attention, not second posting elegiggle and C) indicates that he's probably scum as he isn't hunting for scum. It's a really common thing for wolves to hunt for 3p in order to fake solving as it's both beneficial to their wincon and makes it look like they're solvingyou make two solid reads, others are all prooobably and maaaybe. One is "strongly townlead" and the other is "I don't like the tone of his posts"damo666 wrote: ↑Sat Jan 12, 2019 3:59 pmOK this is where I'm at.
Bozo - getting townier ##unvote
CrimsonFox - assume Mason in absence of cc
damo666 - town
darg - null
demonRHk - immune today but a bit suss. Was fight with LQ engineered.
FoxC - highly suspicious but just might be town doc
Jamiet - I no longer suspect him as SK. Probtown
LordQuas - I don't like the tone of his posts. Scum or SK?
Flash - null
Neph - strongly townlean
Durga - null
Worcej - null (quieter than usual - poss SK?)
Assuming 2 of FoxC, demonmRHK, LordQ are scum/SK then 3 out of my 4 nulls must be scum/SK
##vote LordQuas
If this wagon does not take off I will switch.
it's d3 surely you have more to your reads beyond not liking a tone, that's such a cop out reasoning for someone who doesn't know how to sell a lynch, why don't you like my tone? what pings you about it?
I concede there are more obvious lynch candidates and fair enough for you to townREAD him but how townCLEAR?
There had been a strong consensus overnight that Bozo vs Foxcastle would be very informative. And it looked like Bozo was saved EoD1damo666 wrote: ↑Sat Jan 12, 2019 7:16 pmActually you were the first to vote Bozo D3 so you put him in the lead! So what was your reason?Jamiet99uk wrote: ↑Sat Jan 12, 2019 7:10 pmI put my vote on Bozo when he was one of the lead wagons.
Latterly I re-entered that vote so it would show on the bot for anyone doing VCA.
I am now satisfied to ##VOTE FOXCASTLE
Note; for this phase, rename it "would not lynch" or whatever you want if it makes you've feel betterdamo666 wrote: ↑Sat Jan 12, 2019 7:22 pmI concede there are more obvious lynch candidates and fair enough for you to townREAD him but how townCLEAR?
typically that would mean darg is more likely then foxc, but honestly it's not a great indicator, plenty of OGI factors can play into itbozotheclown wrote: ↑Sat Jan 12, 2019 6:44 pmWhat do you think this says about the chances Foxcastle and dargorygel are scum?
I'm hoping he meant town reads cause I don't think about half of those ppl are clear
lol wtf that's not even a tone thing, nor was it orchestrated, you wanna make a specific statement instead of a broad, vague one?damo666 wrote: ↑Sat Jan 12, 2019 7:19 pmThe orchestrated fight with demon mostlyLordQuas wrote: ↑Sat Jan 12, 2019 6:14 pmdamo666 wrote: ↑Sat Jan 12, 2019 6:06 pm
I'm not particularly SK and I don't understand how you say I am not scum hunting. There are 5 outstanding anti-town roles 4 scum and 1 SK. I am endeavouring to identify as many of the 5 as I can. I suspect a minimum of 2 from Fox/LordQ/demonRHK with the rest from worcej/darg/Durga/flash. Of course I could be misreading Bozo Jamie or Neph but I doubt it. I don't see that as 'hedgy'.you make two solid reads, others are all prooobably and maaaybe. One is "strongly townlead" and the other is "I don't like the tone of his posts"damo666 wrote: ↑Sat Jan 12, 2019 3:59 pmOK this is where I'm at.
Bozo - getting townier ##unvote
CrimsonFox - assume Mason in absence of cc
damo666 - town
darg - null
demonRHk - immune today but a bit suss. Was fight with LQ engineered.
FoxC - highly suspicious but just might be town doc
Jamiet - I no longer suspect him as SK. Probtown
LordQuas - I don't like the tone of his posts. Scum or SK?
Flash - null
Neph - strongly townlean
Durga - null
Worcej - null (quieter than usual - poss SK?)
Assuming 2 of FoxC, demonmRHK, LordQ are scum/SK then 3 out of my 4 nulls must be scum/SK
##vote LordQuas
If this wagon does not take off I will switch.
it's d3 surely you have more to your reads beyond not liking a tone, that's such a cop out reasoning for someone who doesn't know how to sell a lynch, why don't you like my tone? what pings you about it?
A little of both. And apologies, Friday night + Saturday == not following game as closely as I should.
I mean, my vote is pretty justified to save myself. So please take that into consideration.damo666 wrote: ↑Sat Jan 12, 2019 7:41 pmVoters to move off Bozo day 1 were:
Foxcastle
Worcej
Vecna (town).
So if Bozo was saved maybe the scumteam is Bozo/Foxc/Worcej+ a.n.o. (LQ would be my fav).
Now neither Bozo and worcej have a vote and LQ not gaining traction so
##vote Foxcastle. Apols if u r town doc.
