MAFIA XXXVII: THE WHEEL OF WEB-TIME

[Jamiet99uk]

Boso and jamie where did you go

Are you guys discussing

In

Mafia

Qt

What to do??

Prob concede tbh

What's this rubbish? I clearly scumread both Peterlund and Teacher. I'm still thinking Peter is scum.

[peterlund]

What's this rubbish? I clearly scumread both Peterlund and Teacher. I'm still thinking Peter is scum.

Jamie. How do you explain you claiming a non-existent role, the COP? That is really hard for me to understand.

[bozotheclown]

Check Page 57 to like 62

Who is the hardest to push Teacher?

DoubtingThomas

Who is the hardest to defend Teacher?

Bozo

Who falsely claims I am defending Peter hard?

Jamie

Yep scum. Both of them.

Thinking Vacna or Brain is prob sk

Lynch jamie d3

The game is rarely that simple.

It might not be simple, but you just made it simple

If I were a townie in your position, I would try to explain or suggest something else that could be true

You saying, “the game is not simple” does not help the case and if you are an actual townie, you are just being a bad player and makes you look like a scum playing the bluff card

From the way you act, there is absolutely no way you are a VT you hardly care about someone deducing you as a scum

Maybe you might be a sk, as t looks like you were trying to tie the vote by moving to vote teacher who you refrained from doing so for 5 pages until there was enough chaos

Either way vote you d3, as it stands you are a toxic player for townies even if you are actually townie

I will answer any questions you have, but I think most town players will consider I was just wrong about teacher. More than half the remaining players were voting for peter, there are other places you can look if you are sure the remaining scum were trying to protect teacher instead of bussing him.

[bozotheclown]

Boso and jamie where did you go

Are you guys discussing

In

Mafia

Qt

What to do??

Prob concede tbh

What's this rubbish? I clearly scumread both Peterlund and Teacher. I'm still thinking Peter is scum.

There is no chance teacher would make an easily countered PR claimed to try to get peter lynched if peter was scum.

[flash2015]

I would put good money, even go all in on Jamie being scum...but I don't truly understand the talk about bozo. He switched from peter to teacher to put teacher back in the lead for the lynch. That doesn't sound like a scum move to me.

[flash2015]

DoubtingThomas, I am a bit concerned that you are trying a little too hard here...

[brainbomb]

Boso and jamie where did you go

Are you guys discussing

In

Mafia

Qt

What to do??

Prob concede tbh

We dont actually concede here unless chaqa is playing

[brainbomb]

https://imgur.com/a/EJcQRDK

Let the shitposting commence! (or continue I guess)

Chaqa in his hot rod

[brainbomb]

Jamie makes more sense as just town or sk now

[Squigs44]

Jamie makes more sense as just town or sk now

What do you make of Jamie's cop claim when cop doesnt exist? If he was mafia he probably wouldn't have done that. Same reasoning why Peter gets a townread. Jamie wouldnt have role claimed just to put the vote back onto a teammate. Actually, in the panic, Jamie could have done just that. Makes sense if he is SK trying to stay alive. Or he was town and was trying to keep the vote on teacher. That could conceivably make sense. Claim a non existent role so that you don't risk having a real PR counterclaim. Although I'm not sure Jamie could think that through in the EoD confusion. That seems more of something brain would do.
I think SK is the most likely explanation for this.

[Jamiet99uk]

Teacher29 (5): peterlund, yavuzovic, doubtingthomas, rdrivera, foxcastle
Jamiet99uk (7): brainbomb, Vecna, worcej, teacher2, flash2015, bozo, squigs

this means peter is cleared town

How is Peter a townclear?

Don't be absurd. That's pure nonsense.

[Jamiet99uk]

For the same of clarity, I'm not Cop.
No such role exists.
I claimed Cop with around 5 seconds to go, just to take the piss if I was lynched.

[bozotheclown]

Teacher29 (5): peterlund, yavuzovic, doubtingthomas, rdrivera, foxcastle
Jamiet99uk (7): brainbomb, Vecna, worcej, teacher2, flash2015, bozo, squigs

this means peter is cleared town

How is Peter a townclear?

Don't be absurd. That's pure nonsense.

peter is clear because:
1. teacher would not make a fake claim to get a scum teammate lynched
2. peter would not make a fake counterclaim to get a scum teammate lynched

[Squigs44]

Teacher's interactions with worcej d1 are interesting. Will elaborate more after EoN.

[bozotheclown]

Jamie makes more sense as just town or sk now

What do you make of Jamie's cop claim when cop doesnt exist? If he was mafia he probably wouldn't have done that. Same reasoning why Peter gets a townread. Jamie wouldnt have role claimed just to put the vote back onto a teammate. Actually, in the panic, Jamie could have done just that. Makes sense if he is SK trying to stay alive. Or he was town and was trying to keep the vote on teacher. That could conceivably make sense. Claim a non existent role so that you don't risk having a real PR counterclaim. Although I'm not sure Jamie could think that through in the EoD confusion. That seems more of something brain would do.
I think SK is the most likely explanation for this.

Jamie did this after flash and you had voted for him, so I think it was just a joke because he thought he had been lynched. However, I think he could have done that as town or scum.

[bozotheclown]

Check Page 57 to like 62

Who is the hardest to push Teacher?

DoubtingThomas

Who is the hardest to defend Teacher?

Bozo

Who falsely claims I am defending Peter hard?

Jamie

Yep scum. Both of them.

Thinking Vacna or Brain is prob sk

Lynch jamie d3

The game is rarely that simple.

It might not be simple, but you just made it simple

If I were a townie in your position, I would try to explain or suggest something else that could be true

You saying, “the game is not simple” does not help the case and if you are an actual townie, you are just being a bad player and makes you look like a scum playing the bluff card

From the way you act, there is absolutely no way you are a VT you hardly care about someone deducing you as a scum

Maybe you might be a sk, as t looks like you were trying to tie the vote by moving to vote teacher who you refrained from doing so for 5 pages until there was enough chaos

Either way vote you d3, as it stands you are a toxic player for townies even if you are actually townie

To address your comment/question as to why I voted for teacher when I did, teacher claimed to be a town PR when faced with a likely lynch, but did not say which PR. Not specifying a PR looks suspicious, since it is not possible for the real PR to counterclaim. Still, lynching an uncontested PR claimant should be avoided, but I already had my vote on peter. Then peter claimed doc with only four minutes to go, and even though teacher tried to then claim vet, it was obviously in response to peter's doc claim, so peter's claim was more believable. That is when I switched my vote to teacher. After that I was watching the push to vote Jamie to avoid lynching either of the PR claimants, but I did not think he would get enough votes in time. My vote brought the vote from 7-6 teacher to 8-5 teacher, so I do not know why you would interpret that as an attempt to tie the vote.

[BismarckAlive]

#1329
Post by brainbomb » Mon Jul 16, 2018 9:13 pm
Okay, so if tracker tracked me N1, I am proven to have carried out neither kill.

Brainbomb,
Can you please clarify whether in N1 you were visited or role-blocked?

[ND]

##GM NOTE:
Dear Players: Thank you for your patience. We have reviewed the matter and believe the adjudication call was correct.

[DoubtingThomas]

The game is rarely that simple.

It might not be simple, but you just made it simple

If I were a townie in your position, I would try to explain or suggest something else that could be true

You saying, “the game is not simple” does not help the case and if you are an actual townie, you are just being a bad player and makes you look like a scum playing the bluff card

From the way you act, there is absolutely no way you are a VT you hardly care about someone deducing you as a scum

Maybe you might be a sk, as t looks like you were trying to tie the vote by moving to vote teacher who you refrained from doing so for 5 pages until there was enough chaos

Either way vote you d3, as it stands you are a toxic player for townies even if you are actually townie

To address your comment/question as to why I voted for teacher when I did, teacher claimed to be a town PR when faced with a likely lynch, but did not say which PR. Not specifying a PR looks suspicious, since it is not possible for the real PR to counterclaim. Still, lynching an uncontested PR claimant should be avoided, but I already had my vote on peter. Then peter claimed doc with only four minutes to go, and even though teacher tried to then claim vet, it was obviously in response to peter's doc claim, so peter's claim was more believable. That is when I switched my vote to teacher. After that I was watching the push to vote Jamie to avoid lynching either of the PR claimants, but I did not think he would get enough votes in time. My vote brought the vote from 7-6 teacher to 8-5 teacher, so I do not know why you would interpret that as an attempt to tie the vote.

who are your scum read and explain, please

[worcej]

##GM NOTE:
Dear Players: Thank you for your patience. We have reviewed the matter and believe the adjudication call was correct.

Your the GM - what you says goes anyways :)